Why due diligence comes first
GEO is a new category — no official leaderboard, no shared standard, results lagging by a sampling cycle: ideal for sales talk. Judge a provider by its method, data and stated limits — not by its self-description. Twelve questions follow — each with a credible answer and a bad-answer signal. Mismatched answers: do not sign yet.
Set 1: Measurement
1. Which question panel and engines do you measure on, and how often? Credible: fixed question list, engine list and cadence, compared over time. Red flag: the questions change every report, or proof is a single screenshot.
2. How exactly are mention rate and citation rate defined? Can we see the raw answers? Credible: definitions written down, applied consistently, raw sampling records available. Red flag: one composite score, definitions going fuzzy when asked.
3. What is our baseline, and how are targets set? Credible: baseline first; targets layered by crawling, mentions, citations. Red flag: a promise to double results before any baseline exists. Note: Negency's flagship 30-site data (30 Chinese exporters' global website home domains; audit engine, around 30 signals, five categories; single-day sample, 30 October 2026) measures website technical visibility only, not mention rates — a technical score is not a mention-rate baseline.
Set 2: Method and limits
4. Which layers do you actually work on? Credible: crawl reachability, machine readability, entity consistency, citation ecosystem, each with its own deliverables. Red flag: one vague "proprietary playbook".
5. Can you guarantee our brand appears in AI answers, ranked first? Credible: no — a citation in a natural answer cannot be bought; outcomes depend on engine sampling, so the work raises probabilities and verifies with data. Red flag: guaranteed placement or ranking, fees per "ranking achieved". Google's docs confirm there are no additional technical requirements for AI Overviews or AI Mode.
6. What role does llms.txt play in your method? Credible: an optional aid, not the core, not a pass — and they can state Google's official position. Red flag: llms.txt or some "AI-only tag" sold as a secret weapon. The proposal is public at llmstxt.org — a convention, not a standard.
7. How is content produced? Will hundreds of generated articles land on our site? Credible: content built page by page around real customer questions, with fact-checking and standards. Red flag: hundreds of auto-generated articles a month.
Set 3: Evidence and deliverables
8. Can we see your own website's GEO data? Credible: their own site first, with measured mention, citation and crawl records. Red flag: polished client screenshots only, their own data always confidential. Negency's own website scored 97/100 in an audit on 11 November 2026 (performance and basics 80, homepage response 3.08s) — our own sample first.
9. What exactly is delivered, and how often? Credible: audit reports, fix lists, sampling scorecards, re-measurement comparisons; samples available, cadence fixed. Red flag: the only deliverable is a monthly "work summary".
10. How long until results, judged by what? Credible: layered timelines — engineering in two to four weeks, mentions and citations as quarterly trends — naming the engine sampling cycle as a variable nobody controls. Red flag: "results in 7 days". The full three-clocks explanation: How long does GEO take to show results?
Set 4: Contract and risk
11. How is pricing structured? Can we pilot first? Credible: diagnostic, pilot and ongoing service separated, with pilot acceptance metrics. Red flag: annual-only contract, full prepayment, a pilot with no acceptance criteria.
12. Who owns the data, accounts and content assets? How does exit work? Credible: sampling data, content and accounts belong to the client; handover checklist on exit. Red flag: data locked in their system, deleted when the contract ends. Put it in the contract.
Red flags and green flags
Red flags: guaranteed placement or ranking, refusal to show raw samples, a secret method, one file or tag sold as the secret, bulk content farming, no baseline. Green flags: fixed panel and definitions, inspectable raw answers, their own website as the first sample, layered timelines, limits stated up front.
After the questions
Three buckets. Disqualifiers: guaranteed ranking, refusal to show raw samples, data not belonging to the client — any one ends it. Negotiables: price, cadence, pilot scope — write agreed terms into the contract. Tie-breakers: their own website as the first sample, limits stated up front, published samples — they settle close calls.
Negency's positions are public on this site: What is GEO?, How do you measure a brand's visibility in AI answers?, Going Global from China: How to Choose an AI Consulting and GEO Partner.
Pick the kind first
Settle the kind first: four kinds of GEO provider, compared puts all four on one yardstick. Weighing software against a service? Start with GEO tools vs a GEO agency.